BGiME #10: Making a Rohirrim Building

This is perhaps my favorite “Modelling Workshop” to date. Issue #10 provides detailed instructions on making low-cost but good-looking houses for Rohan. Their appearance, however, is generic enough to suit most Dark Ages or medieval periods, and they can easily pull double-duty as a Western European structure if your wargaming tastes lean towards the historical as well as Middle-earth.

The basic box shape of the house means you can use any rectangular object of the correct size as the building’s base. I followed the instructions and used some old tea boxes, but anything close to that scale would also work. If you’re overly ambitious, you could even build the base from scratch with heavy cardboard or foam board.

The roof “thatch” is ordinary spackle diluted down to a toothpaste consistency and painted on. Once laid down over the cardboard roof, lines are etched into the joint compound with a toothpick to give it the correct texture. Painted properly, the fake thatch looks fantastic and has so far proven durable.

I know later issues of Battle Games in Middle-earth demonstrate other methods of building Rohan structures, but I’d be surprised if you can make them for cheaper. It took me roughly a week of on-and-off building to create, texture, and paint these up. A long weekend of steady attention would probably suffice if you needed them faster. All in all, these are amazing terrain pieces. Combine them with the watch beacon from last issue and you have an eye-catching Rohan or Dark Age hamlet for your tabletop battles.

Under Construction: You can see the balsa wood trimmings and dried "thatch" roof ready for painting

Spackle covers the base to give it texture as well.

Painted with flocked base.

I like the horse-head roof emblems, but would probably make them from foam board or balsa wood if I had to do it again.

The doorknob is a drop of hardened white glue painted silver.

A good view of the "thatching."

Rear view.

Battle Games in Middle-earth Issue #10 Overview

Double digits at last! This whimsical project has advanced in fits and starts—and will undoubtedly continue to lurch forward in a similar manner—but we’ve finally made it to issue #10. And with it, we’re almost at an end of learning the basics of the Strategy Battle Game. Just in time for a whole new edition to be released, if signs from Games Workshop are indication. But we’ll cross that Bridge of Khazad-dûm when we get to it. Let’s look at BGiME #10.

The magazine begins as always with the “Guide to Middle-earth.” Issue #10 gives us the low down on Saruman’s most brutal warriors: the fighting Uruk-hai. From their emergence from the birthing pits beneath Orthanc to their appetite for man-flesh, we learn how Saruman mixes magic and science to create perhaps the fiercest soldiers of the end of the Third Age. A look at the Uruk-hai was a natural choice as this issue not only features the conclusion of the “Burn the Village!” scenario (where the Uruk-hai threaten to massacre the brave men of Rohan), but also comes with a new sprue of Uruk-hai warriors to add to our collection.

Moving on to the “Playing the Game” chapter, we learn a lesson in Courage. Or at least how the Courage stat works in the SBG. There’s a caveat here, though. The Courage rules presented in issue #10 are the old way Courage worked in the game. In the original rules as released with The Fellowship of the Ring boxed set, Courage tests were a much more complex system. When certain conditions arose, such as after a force had lost 50% or more of its models (and considered "broken") or a model found itself on its own, each model the condition applied to had to make a Courage test. This involved rolling 2d6 and adding the model’s Courage score to the result. If the total was 10+, the model passed its Courage test and play continued as normal.

However, if a model failed its Courage test, things got complicated. The model was forced to Retreat, turning directly away from the nearest enemy model and moving its maximum movement distance in that direction. Its Move was then over for that turn. If Courage test conditions continued to apply to the model in subsequent rounds, new tests would have to be made, possibly resulting in the model fleeing off the board completely and being treated as a casualty for victory conditions.

This Courage system made concessions towards realism, but proved awkward in play. Later editions streamlined the rules for Courage. Models on their own no longer had to make tests. Figures trying to charge a foe with the Terrifying quality now made their Courage test before moving toward the model (remaining still if the test failed). In the case of broken forces, any model failing its test was immediately removed from the board. This method was much simpler than making consecutive Courage tests until a model left the field of battle.

Heroes play an important role in Courage tests thanks to the “Stand Fast!” rule. In short, any Hero that makes its Courage test negates the need for all friendly models within 6” to make Courage tests of their own. A stout-hearted Good Hero could prevent the ranks from breaking and fleeing, while cruel Evil Heroes kept their lackeys in line out of sheer fear.

The chapter closes with the suggestion to go back and replay some of the old scenarios and see how they turn out with the Courage tests now invoked. It’s possible “The Last Alliance” or “Pursuit of the Ringwraiths” could have much different endings when forces break or when heroes lose their resolve. 

Next up is the conclusion of the “Burn the Village” battle report the “Battle Game” section. No new scenario is included in this issue. Instead, we get a post-battle breakdown of the scenario as played by two employees of Games Workshop. This report covers turns 5-9 and is well-written, but suffers a bit from photographic demonstrations of the various fights and maneuvers. Nevertheless, it serves as a good example of how the SBG is played and suggests tactics to newcomers. I won’t reveal how the game turns out, aside from it had a different ending that either of the matches we played ourselves!

Moving along to the “Painting Workshop,” we’re introduced to a method that every miniature wargamer who actually wants to play must master: batch painting. Tips on using spray primer, dry-brushing, using large brushes, pre-mixing paint, and stage-by-stage (or “assembly line”) painting of models are all covered. If we follow this advice, we should have our newest 10 Uruk-hai finished and ready for the table in no time.

The last section, “Modelling Workshop,” presents us with our most complex piece of tabletop terrain to date: a Rohirrim building. This will be our first intact building for Middle-earth and the challenge could be quite daunting. Luckily, the simple shape of the building provides us with some shortcuts to create an excellent piece of scenery, one that will serve us well in not only The Lord of the Rings SBG battles but other Dark Age and medieval period historical wargames such as SAGA or Frostgrave. The finished piece really is good-looking and the step-by-step directions are instructive without being opaque.

As we close the issue, the back cover gives us a look at the next issue headed for the newsagent. We can look forward to a metal Boromir model, new rules that “set your Heroes apart from lesser warriors,” an attack at Amon-hen, and how to construct a standing stone for our battlefields. All this and more await us in issue #11!

With our overview, well, over, let’s take a more detailed look at what Battle Games in Middle-earth #10 adds to our The Lord of the Rings SBG gaming table, starting with 10 new Uruk-hai for our inventory of Evil models…

BGiME #9: Burn the Village! Part 1

The scenario in issue #9 is played across two issues as a battle report recounting the outcome of the battle as fought by two Games Workshop employees. To reflect this, I’ll discuss the scenario in two parts. The first is a recap of the battle wherein my friend and regular opponent, Dave, played the forces of Good while I commanded Evil. For the issue #10 coverage, I’ll discuss how the game turned out when it was my turn to command the Good warriors of Middle-earth.

“Burn the Village!” features a small Rohan hamlet facing off against a horde of Uruk-hai. The Rohirrim are outnumbered and facing heavily-armored enemies. Their only hope is the timely arrival of the Three Hunters—Aragon, Legolas, and Gimli—who are passing nearby in pursuit of the captured hobbits when Rohan is attacked. If the Rohirrim can light a signal beacon calling for aid, the three heroes rush to lend their assistance—hopefully before the troops of the White Hand burn down the village’s two buildings!

Mechanically, once Good lights the signal beacon, the Rohan player rolls 1d6 for each of the three heroes on subsequent turns. If the roll is 4+, that hero arrives on the table side with the beacon and can charge immediately into battle.

Likewise, in order for the Uruk-hai to burn down a building, one or more of their models must be in base contact with the structure and not be involved in combat. Additionally, no Good model can also be in contact with the building and not be engaged in battle. If these conditions are met, each applicable Evil model rolls 1d6 and on a result of “6” the building catches fire and is destroyed.

In the first game, Dave set most of the Rohan warriors up behind the village’s walls, giving him the benefit of defending an obstacle in the forthcoming fight ("In the way" rolls, single combats, etc. as explained in issue #7). I had only four archers and arrayed them on either side of the path from the village to the beacon. It was my hope to kill any Rohan troops running to the beacon before they could light it. Dave countered by sending two troops off towards the beacon, while I moved the rest of my forces towards the village from three sides.

The walls worked in the favor of Rohan at the beginning, stalling my efforts to get inside the village and kill enough of the Rohirrim so that I could set the buildings alight unimpeded. Eventually, however, one or two Rohan Warriors were slain despite the walls’ protection and I sent Uruk-hai leaping inside the perimeter. Once the levy broke, the tide of the White Hand overwhelmed the Rohan forces inside.

Dave had terrible luck with reinforcements. He managed to get the signal beacon lit by the end of Turn 3, but failed every reinforcement roll (three each round!) to get the Good heroes onto the board and help turn the tide of battle. He might have gotten Gimli onto the board near the end of the game (it's been awhile since we played this battle and my memory is spotty), but the dwarf’s short legs didn’t get him anywhere near the fight before I surrounded the Rohan houses with multiple models and burned them to the ground. Score one victory for Evil!

Next, it would be me turn to command Rohan. Could I do any better? We’ll find out when coverage of Battle Games in Middle-earth #10 occurs shortly!

The forces are arranged for battle

The Uruk-hai approach as Dave measures out the movement of the Rohan warrior headed towards the signal beacon.

Uruk-hai supported by pikemen approach the village wall while Rohan prepares to receive them.

The battle is joined!

Uruk-hai have breached the village's defenses!

The signal fire is lit! Help must come to Rohan!

Rohan falls back to defend the village's building from the flames of Saruman's troops.

Surrounded!

The forces of Rohan have been slain and the buildings are burned. Victory for Evil!

BGiME #9: Constructing a Warning Beacon

This is a cool piece of terrain that was fun to build. The warning beacon has a lot of character and its presence in one's inventory of tabletop decor suggests many potential game ideas. It could summon reinforcements as it does in this issue's battle scenario. It could be an objective to be protected for X number of turns while a model frantically kindle the beacon. It could even be a pyre upon which a hapless model is to be burned alive unless he or she is rescued. All of these are intriguing uses of the terrain piece to liven up any tabletop battle.

The piece was easy to construct using materials I already had on hand. I built it along with some Rohan houses that also made an appearance in this issue's scenario. I'll post separate images of those when I cover the next issue. Please forgive the unattractive backdrop for this series of photos. I took them without much thought of posting them online and snapped them merely to brag to a friend about what I'd accomplished.

 

Battle Games in Middle-earth #9 Overview

There’s been a lot happening on the Middle-earth scene of late. Games Workshop is releasing their new Middle-earth Battle Companies supplement (bearing the new Middle-Earth Strategy Battle Game logo!) imminently. Amazon has announced they’re developing a new series based on the years prior to the Lord of the Rings. I’ve become a huge fan of the “Exploring The Lord of the Rings” podcast, and my local gaming group is starting a new The One Ring campaign next month. So, with Middle-earth excitement waxing strongly, let’s delve back into this on-going series, shall we?

Battle Games in Middle-earth #9 starts off with the usual “Guide to Middle-earth” section, and it’s a short one. It’s also more meta than in previous issues. Little detail is given to Middle-earth and the chapter instead explains that issue #9 will feature its first Battle Report. In this issue and in #10, a game between two players will be covered in some detail, describing how events occurred during the game and the strategy behind the players’ actions. That scenario, included in this issue, features a band of Uruk-hai assaulting a Rohan village. Unlike the similar scenario in issue #7, this time, the Rohirrim have a chance of receiving some powerful reinforcements in the guise of Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli—assuming they can hold out that long. We’ll see how that plays out later.

“Playing the Game”continues the trend begun in the previous issue by detailing the various melee (or mêlée as the European-based publication prints it) weapons encountered on the battlefields of Middle-earth. These include hand weapons, two-handed weapons, spears, pikes, and shields. Rules for each are also provided, bringing a new level of complexity and tactics to your table. Two-handed weapons, for example, subtract 1 from their rolls during the Fight phase to determine who wins a battle, but add 1 to all rolls to wound opponents if the wielder wins the fight. Spears and pikes allow friendly models to support allies, giving them an additional attack die, but they’re not considered to be part of the melee when determining certain factors such as who can be struck by enemies. Shields are great for defense and a model can actively employ a shield to survive a fight, effectively doubling his dice to determine the winner, but the model cannot cause wounds if it wins.

The “Battle Game” section includes the scenario “Burn the Village!” As described above, this scenario pits twelve Warriors of Rohan against a score of Uruk-hai and their Captain. Normally, as we saw in a previous issue, the Rohirrim would be hard-pressed to win. Luckily, this battle includes a rule that allows the Warrior of Rohan to call for reinforcements. If they manage to light a warning beacon, Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli, en route to Isengard to save Merry and Pippin, see the fire and rush to the aid of Rohan. That is, if the Good player rolls 4 or higher on the turn after the warning beacon is set alight. Can the Warriors of Rohan survive long enough for the three hunters to save them or will the Uruk-hai burn down their village and win the battle? We’ll see how that went on our table in an upcoming post.

Also tacked on to the “Battle Game” chapter is the first half of the Battle Report. This after-action report describes Turns 1 through 4 of a game between BGiMe writers Mark Latham and Darron Bowley. Rohan is holding during these early turns and has managed to light the beacon, calling Aragorn to their aid. But the tide might be turning as a force of Uruk-hai leaps over the village walls and engages the Warriors in the heart of the settlement. We’ll see how the forces of Good fare next issue when the Battle Report concludes.

“Painting Workshop” covers two topics. The first is an overview/refresher course of the various painting techniques we’ve learned in the previous issues. Dry-brushing, silver edging, washes, using multiple layers to achieve flat colors, mixing paints, black lining, and basing are all discussed one final time. This reiteration of techniques will prove handy with this issue’s model, as it uses most of them to achieve its quality paint job.

The second half of the chapter is the usual step-by-step instruction for painting issue #9’s included model, a metal Uruk-hai Captain. Uruk-hai are great models to paint as they are simple to do and can be knocked out rather swiftly. Which is good, because we have a lot of Uruk-hai to field in this issue’s Battle Game! With the Uruk-hai Captain in our collection, we’ve got a strong nucleus for an Isengard army: 10 infantry, Lurtz to lead them, and now a Captain to assist. Next issue will have more Uruk-hai, bringing our Evil collection up to 20 Uruk-hai Warriors and two Heroes to lead them. That’s not bad for ten issues of gaming goodness from our local news merchant! 

The issue’s final section, “Modelling Workshop” describes how to build a great piece of terrain: the Rohan warning beacon.” While unlikely to get a lot of regular use, the piece is cool looking and has a lot of character. It’ll likely come in handy down the road once Gondor calls for aid, but in the meanwhile, it gives your table a wonderful decoration that’s outside the normal hedges, trees, and walls. I’m sure I can also think of some new scenarios both in the SBG and other miniature wargames to give me more excuses to use it.

As usual, the issue’s back cover provides a glimpse into the future. In two weeks—in the original print run, I mean—we can expect another sprue of plastic Uruk-hai, the rules for Courage (long overdue in my opinion!), and the conclusion to the “Burn the Village” scenario and Battle Report. It also marks our making it out of the single-digit issues. It only took two-and-a-half years, but it looks like we’re going to do it.

But first, we’ll take a look at how to paint up an Uruk-hai Captain. See you soon!

BGiME #7: Repel the Marauders! Part 2

This scenario was run a second time two weeks ago. A friend and I play miniature wargames every Tuesday night at a FLGS and I thought it time to brush the dust off my Lord of the Rings SBG models and get caught up with this blog. I’ve proposed that the first game night of each month be dedicated to the SBG and Dave readily agreed. That should keep me up to date on my painting, building, and working my way through this series.

While the models used in this game are the same as the previous one, you’ll notice the terrain has enjoyed a slight upgrade. The buildings are my Rohan-style houses I built a few months back. We’ll cover those more in a future discussion about "Battle Games in Middle-earth."

The Warriors of Rohan rush to man the walls around their village.

The Uruk-hai slowly advance across the Riddermark.

The scent of man-flesh hangs heavy in the air, driving the servants of the White Hand forward!

A high view of the battle about to commence.

"They are upon us, men!"

The Uruk-hai have scaled the fences!

Battle rages along the length of the walls.

Rohan holds back some of the Uruk-hai, but for how long?

Pikeman surge forward to push back the Men of Rohan.

The battle reaches a fevered pitch!

Rohan begins to falter.

Two Uruk-hai engage a single Warrior of Rohan.

The melee swirls around the verge of the village as Rohan is overwhelmed.

The last Man of Rohan perishes under Uruk-hai numbers.

The battle begins anew!

The Servants of the White Hand spread their forces about the village boundary.

Archers conceal themselves behind the rocks.

An early hole in Rohan's defenses is discovered!

A solitary Uruk-hai holds his own...briefly.

The hole is closed and the Uruk-hai are pushed back!

As Rohan begins to fail, I discover I didn't take more photos.

Rohan lost both matches this time around. In retrospect, I'm to blame. I failed to refresh myself with this issue of BGiME and was using the rules for Courage and broken forces, something that hadn't been introduced to the readers of the magazine yet. So instead of Rohan being able to fight to the last man without issue, I was having them make Courage tests to remain on the field after they had been "broken" (lost more than 50% of their force). That might have made a difference in the battles.

Even without the Courage rules in play, this scenario is a tough one for Rohan. The Uruk-hai are one of the meanest forces in the original SBG. They are heavily armored, have high Fight score, and are strong, making them tough opponents. Without cavalry to back them up or similarly armored or better fighters on Rohan's side, the odds were stacked against the forces of Good. It will be interesting to see how Rohan fares in a few issues when they gain Heroes to help them and horses to ride. Stay tuned for that in upcoming posts.

Next up: making walls and fences.

BGiME #7: Repel the Marauders! Part 1

A horde of Uruk-hai bears down upon a Rohan settlement. Can its brave defenders hold them off long enough for the rest of the village to flee? That is the premise of this scenario, designed to recreate one of the many minor skirmishes that occurred in Rohan leading up to the Battle of Helm’s Deep. It also puts the newly-learned rules for defending barriers to good use. How does Rohan fare against the Uruk-hai? Let’s find out:

I’ve played through this scenario four times at two different occasions. Once was a couple of years back when I was organizing a short-lived SBG group, and the second was just a couple weeks ago. These images are from the first pair of games:

The start of the battle. Uruk-hai are positioned behind the hill, while Rohan holds the wall.

The Uruk-hai advance!

"They can't hit me if they can't see me!"

The heavy Uruk-hai armor shrugs off Rohan's arrows as they clamber over the hill.

"Hold the wall, men!"

"I smell man-flesh!"

The battle is joined. Rohan holds for now, but the Uruk-hai seek to climb and unprotected fence.

"These crossbows are pretty sweet!"

A view from the ruins.

Uruk-hai breech!

"Fight for your lives!"

"I can pick those men off from here. I don't mind if I shoot a few friendlies if I miss. I'm Evil, after all!"

I'm going on hazy memory here, but I believe Rohan won one battle and lost the other. This is a tough fight for Good. The Uruk-hai have stronger armor and a higher Fight value. Only the walls keep this from being an utter cake-walk for Evil. Once the Uruk-hai breech the walls, Good has a rough time holding them off. I think Good only won because the players running Evil in that game made some inexperienced decisions, allowing my partner and I to capitalize on their mistakes and squeeze out a win.

The second and more recent play of this scenario will be covered in the next post.